The need for an anti-racism lens in NZ journalism

Which news articles help to create a peaceful society? Which ones, sometimes unintentionally, reproduce racial harm? Once you learn to dissect journalism through an anti-racism lens, the difference is surprisingly simple.

Journalism does not just report an event. The words journalists choose, the voices they amplify, the context analysis they provide and conclusions they highlight all influence the reader’s understanding of such events.

This is especially important when racist remarks or behaviours are reported, because without an anti-racism lens, articles risk spreading racial harm even unintentionally. An anti-racism lens would recognise the impact on communities of repeating racist messages without context of the harm caused by such remarks, as well as thinking about the positioning of such comments and responses within the content.

We believe that journalism covering racist remarks begins – and especially ends – with strong anti-racism messages. This is because readers tend to remember the beginning and ending, but particularly the latter part of articles compared to the middle part, due to differences in our memory retention. In the middle, journalists can provide ‘balance’ and present the problem. But ‘balance’ certainly does not need to mean being neutral to racism.

In comparison, those articles that feature racist incidents and/or are simply repeating toxic messages of certain politicians – without an anti-racism lens – are simply spreading harm and amplifying the problem. Those articles are significantly hurting ethnic community members by either implicitly or explicitly reiterating ‘racism is the norm in New Zealand and there is no consequence for the perpetrators’. Do you know how many of us are being injured and suffering? Way too many.

Here we analyse journalism, using an example of the reporting of Winston Peters’ racist remark towards Green MP Lawrence Xu-Nan. 

Healthy media reporting about this event would include the anti-racism messaging that people who engage in racist remarks and hurt other citizens should be met with consequences: reduced roles or suspension. This would indicate to the rest of the country that racism is not tolerated in Aotearoa New Zealand. 

The articles below are harmful because they lack an anti-racism lens and simply repeat what Peters said, including the fact that he got away without any consequence. The wider NZ white community may be led to think ‘if our foreign minister gets away with it, I can, too.’ This bolsters bullying towards Chinese and other non-white students and adults.

This RNZ’s article features Helen Clark’s opinion, which aligns with an anti-racism lens. However, the last comments by Mr Peters are unchallenged and this is what will be left in a reader’s mind.

This 1 News article could also have been improved by finishing with Xu-Nan’s comment.

A positive feature of this article is that it features a global news organisation’s shock that New Zealand’s democratic ‘image’ has been damaged. However, the ending features the Prime Minister’s problematic narrative, again without challenge or response.

We think this article had positive conclusions about Asian migration and building stronger ties with Asia.

We will end with an exemplary article by Professor Mohan Dutta, which is written with clear anti-racism messages.

In conclusion, good articles are few and very rare among this coverage. We believe that little reporting on toxic content is better than repeating harmful messages. Therefore, we ask media organisations to please think twice before featuring politicians who want to grab votes through using the journalists to spread their toxic racist rants. The news media’s lack of an anti-racism lens is hurting too many. 

For a more positive impact on society, we need all articles featuring racist remarks and behaviours to have strong anti-racism messages at the initial part and, especially the conclusion of the article. A stronger ending for these stories would have given the last word to those affected. Lawrence Xu-Nan’s response, or the voices of Chinese and other ethnic communities, would have shown readers what the remark meant, rather than closing on Peters refusing to apologise.

We have had approximately 190 years of racist reporting in this country, and much longer if you count the legacy of British journalism. Yes, in recent years, there has been improvement. But to tip the balance, NZ journalists need to apply an anti-racism lens to their articles, videos and podcasts. That’s how to win the trust of diverse communities in modern Aotearoa. This is how we create a peaceful society where everyone’s mana is cherished and enhanced.

To learn more about this topic, you can view our online media symposium from October 2025, Bridging the Gap. Also, keep an eye out for our free educational course set for release in November 2026.

He aroha whakatō, he aroha puta mai – if kindness is sown, then kindness you shall receive.

Similar Posts